September 16, 2009
Growing older faster, but without any of the benefits of independence

As part of its Tween Issue, Time Out New York has a great feature by Rebecca Stead (author of the wonderful When You Reach Me), which you can read here. (Thanks to Mitali Perkins for the link.) I’m about the same age as Rebecca, and love her story about working at the Subway for 40 minutes a day, during her lunch break, when she was 11. (A memory she uses in her book.) That’s totally a scene that could have come from my life.

I’ve often thought about all the stuff my sister and I did around San Francisco at seven, eight, nine, ten years old, and I look at the kids that age I know now and am sure their parents would never give them the same freedom. I’m talking about, say, 1975-1980. Specifically I remember:

…riding all around town with my sister, or alone, on the MUNI system. Our family didn’t have a car. Once every couple of weeks my mom’s boss would let her borrow his car to take care of errands, but otherwise it was all bus, all the time. Involving transfers and waiting on street corners, cold and hungry, with no cell phone or iPod. Oh the humanity!

…walking to school by myself. My grade school was about four blocks away, then in fourth grade I moved to one nine blocks away.

…playing out on the streets with other kids until dark.

…playing out on the streets by myself until dark.

…walking to Golden Gate Park with neighborhood friends to hang out on the playground. My friend Rachel and I buried coins in the woods surrounding the Rose Garden and went to dig them up, later.

…going to Mountain Lake Park with my best friend, Christine, and playing forest primeval, and hanging out in caves in the foothills around her dad’s place, pretending to be super-sleuths. Totally isolated.

…in sixth grade, my school was more like 20 blocks from my house. We’d walk home at a very leisurely pace, up Geary or Clement, stopping for pork buns or piroshki or a Boudin roll, and to look at Hello Kitty stuff, and maybe get home an hour and a half after school was out.

…laundry duty! My sister and I would load up the cart (the kind old Eastern European ladies push/pull home from the grocery store) with dirty clothes, walk the five blocks (uphill!) to the laundromat, and attend to the laundry for a few hours. One thing that made this fun was the wearing of rollerskates, inside the laundromat—until the day my sister fell and busted her chin open, and a KINDLY STRANGER drove us home (I think).

…taking the bus to and from ballet theater performances, two little girls in stage makeup…eyeshadow and lipstick.

…walking up to the community garden by myself and staying there until dark, living out whatever little fantasy game I was playing: the play structure is a ship, or the sand is hot lava, or the basketball court is the Land of the Lost fog pit.

Sometimes my sister (four years older) was with me, but often enough I was alone or with friends my age. We weren’t stupid. If we sensed a car slowing near us we’d ignore it and walk faster and start looking for an adult. Once or twice some random man on the street exposed himself. But, you know, I’m not scarred or anything. It wasn’t like the world was safe and children weren’t being molested and cars weren’t running over people. I was semi-sort of beat up a couple of times on the bus. And I do understand that a city is different from the burbs—with more people on foot and using public transport, you get the panopticon effect (thank you, E. Lockhart, for teaching me a new word!).

In Stead’s article, she quotes Susan Linn: “…these ['tween'] years are a time of great intellectual and creative flowering.” I so buy that. I read more books between the ages of 8 and 12 than I’ve read in the last 20 years, I bet. My imagination was at its very ripest and I distinctly remember that the times I most richly explored it were when I was free from adult supervision or peer judgment. The era, and my mom, gave me the freedom and independence to explore it, and without that I doubt I’d be a writer.

All of this is one of the many reasons I so enjoyed When You Reach Me. Reading it made me feel like I did on those days living my independent little life in the city.

If I had kids I would totally read this book by Lenore Skenazy:

Shop Indie Bookstores

But I don’t, so you should.

3 comments for this post

  • Laura | September 16, 2009 | 6:46 pm

    I can’t find the quote now, of course, but I’ve read Skenazy say that crime rates for kidnapping and stuff are actually way down from the time that these kids’ parents were growing up. So, the parents get all freaked out and say, “But things were so much SAFER when I was a kid!” … but they weren’t. It’s better now, we just have more 24 hour news channels looking for something to get worked up about.

    [Reply]


  • Alexa | September 17, 2009 | 6:55 am

    I grew up in a tiny village in England and so had loads of freedom I’d love my son to have the same kind of childhood but I doubt he will. Even though I’ve read the statistics I still don’t want him out alone (when he’s old enough, he’s only a baby) I think is a combination of the news so we hear about things our parents wouldn’t have and what other parents are doing.

    [Reply]


  • Candi Criddle | September 17, 2009 | 8:23 am

    Thanks for this. My oldest is in Kindergarten and the school requires parents to drop off and pick up which is good for a five year old, but I was even wondering if I’d ever let him walk to school by himself. I’ve even read “Freakonomics” where it semi explains the crime rate drop, I still can’t internalize that.
    When I was a kid (in the 80s) my brother and I used to get ourselves lost in the woods behind our house on purpose just so we’d have to find our way back home with our wits and little compasses.
    It’s good to remember the things I loved about childhood are things I shouldn’t take away from my children.

    [Reply]


Add your comment

Your name:


  Required

Email address:
  Required

Site URL:

Your comment: